Jump to content


Photo
- - - - -

Need help for AR-12 refurbish

midrange resistance

  • Please log in to reply
8 replies to this topic

#1 rumblestrip

rumblestrip

    Newbie

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 1 posts

Posted 04 June 2012 - 01:27 PM

Picked up this pair of AR-12's the other day for a song. Almost passed them by because they have been painted brown over the original walnut veneer so that they looked like cheapies. Otherwise in excellent shape and complete except for the rotted-away foam surrounds and dispersion rings on the tweeters. Got them home only to find that one of the midranges is dead. Took them both out to measure the resistance on the one still working. It metered out at 3.6 ohms. Does this mean the midranges were originally 4 ohm speakers or could they be 6 or even 8? Does anyone have any experience with these so that they would know for sure? If so please let me know. There is very little about this model online. Also, is it worth having just the one recoiled, or should I do both?

Attached Thumbnails

  • DSC05206.JPG
  • DSC05207.JPG
  • DSC05210.JPG
  • DSC05211.JPG
  • DSC05214.JPG
  • DSC05216.JPG


#2 Anthropologo

Anthropologo

    Member

  • Members
  • PipPip
  • 14 posts

Posted 04 June 2012 - 07:22 PM

Picked up this pair of AR-12's the other day for a song. Almost passed them by because they have been painted brown over the original walnut veneer so that they looked like cheapies. Otherwise in excellent shape and complete except for the rotted-away foam surrounds and dispersion rings on the tweeters. Got them home only to find that one of the midranges is dead. Took them both out to measure the resistance on the one still working. It metered out at 3.6 ohms. Does this mean the midranges were originally 4 ohm speakers or could they be 6 or even 8? Does anyone have any experience with these so that they would know for sure? If so please let me know. There is very little about this model online. Also, is it worth having just the one recoiled, or should I do both?

I have a pair that I just picked up at an estate sale - thrown in with other stuff I bought cause the little old estate sale ladies didn't want to have to carry them out if they didn't sell - on these one of the tweeters is blown and I am not going to pay $129 for a used one from a known ebay vendor - that kind of pricing defeats the "do it yourself" ethos that makes this fun, the mid-range surrounds are shot but both drivers are good, woofers will need re-foamed...anyway, as to impedences using my meter: Tweeter 6.6, Mid-Range 6.5, Woofer 6.7 - so, I will keep surfing ebay in the hopes of finding a more reasonably priced spare tweeter or will look for a pair of replacement tweeters and roll the dice....when i refoam I always do both, regardless....cheers

#3 RoyC

RoyC

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 1,445 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Latham, NY

Posted 05 June 2012 - 03:57 AM

The AR-12 was marketed as an 8 ohm speaker. Dcr of the midrange is around 6 ohms.

The last time I checked, there was no replacment available for the midrange foam.

Roy
Roy Champagne

#4 docstocker

docstocker

    Newbie

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 2 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Gosport, England

Posted 11 June 2012 - 08:52 AM

I have a pair of AR12 that I bought very cheaply a few years ago. The midrange is an unusual unit that fits into a cylinder. the spear has a cloth? surround which in the case of my speakers, was broken and unrepairable. I toyed with the idea of cutting up one of my wife's silk scarves into a replacement and then rubberising it but the difficulty of cutting the circle out of the material (and the extended period I would find myself spending sleeping in the shed when my wife found out about her scarf) lead me to look on the internet where I found a small foam replacement that fitted extremely well.
I suspect that the measurable characteristics of the speaker have been significantly changed but the speakers now sound very good indeed. I am not sure that they are not my favourite in my collection.
I think that this midrange had some specific virtues or novelties. Even with my fix I am happy with the sound, never having heard the speaker when it was new and at full spec.
I am not sure that there are many pairs of these speakers around. I anyone is interested I will try and remember where I obtained these foams.
By the way, replacement mid range units I have seen on E bay have had foam replacements of the cloth originals
John

#5 RoyC

RoyC

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 1,445 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Latham, NY

Posted 11 June 2012 - 02:35 PM

I have a pair of AR12 that I bought very cheaply a few years ago. The midrange is an unusual unit that fits into a cylinder. the spear has a cloth? surround which in the case of my speakers, was broken and unrepairable. I toyed with the idea of cutting up one of my wife's silk scarves into a replacement and then rubberising it but the difficulty of cutting the circle out of the material (and the extended period I would find myself spending sleeping in the shed when my wife found out about her scarf) lead me to look on the internet where I found a small foam replacement that fitted extremely well.
I suspect that the measurable characteristics of the speaker have been significantly changed but the speakers now sound very good indeed. I am not sure that they are not my favourite in my collection.
I think that this midrange had some specific virtues or novelties. Even with my fix I am happy with the sound, never having heard the speaker when it was new and at full spec.
I am not sure that there are many pairs of these speakers around. I anyone is interested I will try and remember where I obtained these foams.
By the way, replacement mid range units I have seen on E bay have had foam replacements of the cloth originals
John


John,

I have only seen (deteriorated) foam surrounds on original AR-12 mids. If the surrounds were made of cloth there would be need to replace them. Your source for new foam would be of interest. The repaired AR-12 mids I've been seeing on Ebay these days have new foam surrounds which have been cut and pieced together to fit.

Roy
Roy Champagne

#6 docstocker

docstocker

    Newbie

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 2 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Gosport, England

Posted 11 June 2012 - 07:51 PM

Hi Roy
Thanks for all your useful info on this site. Have been reading it for several years but never felt I had anything useful to contribute.
I have looked again at the old photos I took when restoring the AR12s and although I clearly remember scraping away thick sticky material that I thought was fabric. Looking again today at the pictures I wonder if the material was in fact flat foam.
The replacements were bought from USA via Ebay.
I have only ever bought surrounds from two sources so it must have been either Geoaliwili or speaker works.com
I notice that there is a London UK based seller on Ebay 'onlydiesel0' advertising an AR12 kit.

The surrounds are ridged foam not flat and were not specifically advertised for AR speakers.

The difficulty I had in fitting the foams was from the cone which sits in fluid and can be pulled out or pushed in but needs to be halfway when the foam is attached and no signal applied. It was this added difficulty that made my efforts to cut and fit replacement flat foam surrounds, cut down from larger surrounds, impossible. (for my skill set)

I will try and attach some photos including measurements.

John

#7 RoyC

RoyC

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 1,445 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Latham, NY

Posted 11 June 2012 - 11:24 PM

Hey John,

I'm sure they were only manufactured with foam surrounds. There are certainly no flat surrounds available, so any replacement will have a roll.

The use of shims in the voice coil gap will provide friction, and allow the cone to be set at the correct height when replacing any surround..

Roy
Roy Champagne

#8 Anthropologo

Anthropologo

    Member

  • Members
  • PipPip
  • 14 posts

Posted 23 July 2012 - 09:11 PM

As noted earlier in this thread, several months ago I found a McIntosh 1700, ELAC Miracord 50H, and AR-12s. Early morning estate sale lines here in Austin are always a cultural experience and its a good excuse for breakfast tacos.

More often than not, its a bust but in this case the little cotton-top estate sale lady cared nothing for electronics; we exchanged $65 and contact info for whenever else she might run into these "heavy and messy electronic things with their cords" and I was out the door....

Receiver and turntable work fine - speakers are a mess -
  • both woofers need refoaming
  • both mids need refoaming
  • only one tweeter works - and is an 8 ohm tweeter version - #200011-2 (other tweets from this line are 4 ohm - #200011-1)
However,
  • cabinets are in beautiful shape
  • foam covers are intact
  • both badges are there
  • I am a sucker for AR....
Anyway, am slogging through getting these back to functional and finally got time to post refoaming of AR-12 mids since is a bit out of the ordinary...
01-AR 12 Mid before cleanup_050.JPG 14-AR 12 Mid part number_063.JPG

Foam was purchased at: http://www.speakerwo...com/default.asp

I purchased 2 of item number SWK3 with a 2 15/16 OD and 2" ID - is a good fit

First thing is to scrape off remains of the nasty black, semi-fuzzy residue adhering to the outer frame
02-AR 12 Mid before cleanup_051.JPG

Once that's complete you can better see the rotted surround
03-AR 12 Mid before cleanup_052.JPG 04-AR 12 Mid before cleanup_053.JPG

Next is to remove all of that rotted surround, the interface between the surround and the cone had become somewhat vague over the years, so cautious scraping and the leaving of a slightly less than pristine surface became the process and yielded the following
05-AR 12 Mid after cleanup_054.JPG 06-AR 12 Mid after cleanup_055.JPG 07-AR 12 Mid after cleanup_056.JPG

Time to place surround - the four tick marks provide the boundaries for best shot at centering
09-AR 12 Mid with disk_058.JPG

I use a flexible disk (this one cut from thin plastic container lid, for larger diameters I find posterboard works well) to hold down the inner surface over the cone. After glue is applied, the disk is put in place with a weight on top. I have found that the flexibility of the the disk exerts an even horizontal and somewhat downward force onto the cone that results in a tight, uniform seal.
10-AR 12 Mid disk in place_059.JPG 11-AR 12 Mid weights in place_060.JPG

Then I did outer rim-I do it in quarters (seems to work best for centering) and cut an arc from cardboard that matches the surround arc, apply glue, give the cone a good three finger push or two to center, place the cardboard arc over the surround and weight it down until glue cures. No pictures here.

Disk removed and outer rim sealed as well, mid ready to be put back in cabinet.
12-AR 12 Mid done_061.JPG 13-AR 12 Mid done_062.JPG

When I played them, there was sound: with the working tweeter, and a bad woofer the uppers and mids were clear and distinct. However, with the ferrofluid wrinkle and ridge in the new foam, who knows how close I am to what was original sound.

Nonetheless, if you need to refoam a pair of these and don't want to cut apart, custom fit, and then rebond a larger foam (some methods I have seen used on items sold on ebay) then this is one way to go.

Finally, a question, is there any advantage/danger in using the 4 ohm tweeters rather than a pair of new 8 ohm with close to same efficiency dome replacements from parts express? I don't hold any hopes for finding an AR-12 tweeter anytime soon and these seem to be my best options. Any helpful advice appreciated.....

#9 speaker dave

speaker dave

    Advanced Member

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 465 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Toronto
  • Interests:Vintage audio, psychoacoustics, bicycling, shortwave radio, photography, record collecting (mostly classical piano).

Posted 26 July 2012 - 12:10 PM

That looks like a very clean and professional repair ot me.

I wouldn't worry about having a half roll where the previous surround was flat. Considering the alternative (dead speakers) it seems like a good choice. Clearly AR knew that the excursion required was nil and so gave it a flat surround, but foam surounds are fairly light and I'd bet the response is little changed.

David S.




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users